Could Unknown Eel Species Explain Lake Monster Sightings?
Share
Walk along the edge of a deep lake at dusk and imagine, just for a moment, the water beneath your feet as a layered world—a place with its own rules, its own physics, its own inhabitants that do not care whether we understand them. Lakes are not static. They breathe, they shift, they carry ancient cold in their lower chambers. They are also, as every fisherman knows, home to creatures that rarely break the surface and never give themselves away completely.
For more than a century, people have tried to explain the serpentine shapes reported in lakes around the world. Some cling to the plesiosaur idea. Others talk about giant sturgeon. Some insist the sightings are nothing more than waves, wakes, or the human imagination trying too hard to make sense of ripples.
But one possibility has lingered in scientific circles longer than most cryptid believers realize—something far less fantastical, far more biologically plausible, and perhaps stranger than either side of the debate wants to admit.
What if lake monster sightings are not glimpses of dinosaurs, not misidentified logs, not illusions born from fog and distance?
What if they’re eels?
Not the eels we know.
Not the eels we’ve cataloged.
Something older, larger, and perfectly adapted to places where human eyes don't reach.
The Shape That Keeps Reappearing
When witnesses describe lake monsters, the details vary, but the core silhouette rarely changes. They describe long bodies rolling in a supple wave. They describe dark forms bending beneath the waterline. They describe something with the fluidity of a serpent but the heft of a fish.
Eel-like creatures, in other words.
Some sightings mention humps rising and falling in a line—something most people associate with serpents. But that undulating motion is also a hallmark of anguilliform swimming, the exact locomotion used by eels.
Many eyewitness reports—maybe most—describe movement more than morphology. They describe a sinuous glide. They describe a dark ribbon cutting through the surface. They describe something that moves with purpose but doesn’t break the water like a mammal or float like debris.
When you strip lake monster sightings down to pure motion, the eel explanation suddenly stands taller than any other.
Eels Already Display the Impossible
The more you study eels, the more alien they become. European eels travel thousands of miles to spawn in the Sargasso Sea, but no one has ever conclusively observed the spawning event. American eels shift between freshwater and saltwater like amphibians. Conger eels can reach ten feet in length. Moray eels—though marine—grow beyond twelve feet, and historical accounts mention larger ones.
Eels don’t just swim. They disappear. They thrive in low visibility. They can fold themselves into crevices and trenches. They survive in temperatures and pressures that would kill most fish. They have metabolisms that slow to near stasis. They grow unpredictably. They mature slowly. Their life cycles border on supernatural.
Most importantly: some eel species grow to sizes far beyond what modern biology considered possible even fifty years ago.
When a group of researchers at New Zealand’s Lake Como pulled up a massive eel carcass in the 1980s—over nine feet long and thick as a man’s waist—biologists hesitated before even labeling it. Growth anomalies? Unknown species? Late-stage gigantism?
Imagine that creature alive, glimpsed only in passing, rolling its body across the surface before disappearing. Anyone would call it a monster.
Now imagine something larger.
Lakes Are Perfect Places for Giants
Deep, cold lakes provide a blueprint for gigantism. As long as there’s a stable food source, low predation, and environmental consistency, species can grow to enormous sizes—especially if they’re slow-metabolism creatures like eels.
Unlike mammals or larger fish, eels don’t need constant feeding. They can endure long lean periods. They can sink into crevices. They can retreat into oxygen-poor zones without dying. They can hide in ways larger-bodied animals cannot.
In every lake monster hotspot, the environment aligns perfectly with eel biology:
Loch Ness has low visibility, cold deep pockets, steep underwater walls, and an abundance of fish.
Lake Champlain is massive, with interconnected waterways and seasonal fish runs.
Lake Okanagan holds depths and thermal layers ideal for large bottom-dwelling predators.
Lagarfljót is thick with glacial silt—an eel paradise if one ever existed.
These lakes could harbor creatures that rarely need to surface and never need to expose their entire bodies. A single powerful motion across the surface could create the illusion of a long-necked creature or a chain of humps.
Not because the creature is serpentine.
But because you’re seeing one section of an eel that could stretch twenty, thirty, maybe forty feet in length.
The Bending of Scale
One of the biggest challenges in lake monster sightings is scale estimation. People underestimate how much distortion water, distance, and perspective can create. A submerged object appears larger than it is. A partially surfaced body creates a false sense of continuity. A ten-foot creature rolling across the water can appear twice as long depending on the angle.
Now apply that to something already long, dark, muscular, and moving with a snake-like undulation.
It wouldn’t just seem large—it would seem impossible.
Eels, unlike fish, don’t have rigid bodies. Their entire form bends. A large eel twisting just under the surface could create the illusion of multiple humps. A partial breach might look like a long neck. A brief flick of the tail could look like a massive serpent diving.
The lake doesn’t need to cooperate to make the illusion convincing. The eel does it naturally.
The “Super-Eel Theory” Has Scientific Support
In the 1970s, a few ichthyologists suggested something bold: that lake monsters might be outsized eels. Not plesiosaurs, not primordial reptiles—just extraordinarily large members of the order Anguilliformes.
The idea never fully fell out of favor. It resurfaced in the 2000s when genetic sampling confirmed that Loch Ness does indeed contain eels—a lot of them. Some researchers argued that while most eels are small, nothing theoretically prevents outliers from reaching extreme sizes.
When researchers analyzed the water for environmental DNA, they didn’t find plesiosaur signatures. They didn’t find sturgeon or catfish signatures large enough to explain sightings. But eel DNA? It was everywhere.
This doesn’t prove giant eels exist.
But it does suggest the lake has all the right ingredients to grow them.
The same could be true for many lake monster habitats worldwide.
What an Unknown Eel Species Would Look Like
People imagine giant eels as thicker versions of the ones pulled from rivers or rock pools. But an unknown species could be different—longer, more streamlined, adapted to deep cold water instead of the warmer, shallower habitats typical of known species.
It might have a lighter or darker coloration depending on depth.
It might possess a dorsal fin running the length of its body, creating the illusion of humps.
It might breach in curves rather than straight lines.
It might move in slow, deliberate patterns misread as intelligence.
It might surface rarely, silently, suddenly.
Such a creature would be startling but not fantastical. It would not need to swallow boats or rear its head like a dinosaur. It would only need to break the surface for two seconds—just enough for a fisherman, hiker, or tourist to freeze and whisper, “What was that?”
Then the creature would slip beneath the layer of cold water where sonar scatters and light disappears.
And the lake would return to stillness.
Why an Eel Fits Better Than Anything Else
All lake monster theories have problems. Plesiosaurs defy basic ecology. Giant fish don’t match head and neck descriptions. Mammals need air too often. Amphibians would require breeding populations impossible to hide.
But giant eels?
They solve nearly everything.
They require little surface time.
They match the movement.
They match the body shape.
They can remain hidden indefinitely.
They can survive in deep cold water.
They grow unpredictably.
They already exist.
All that’s missing is proof of the giant form.
And deep lakes are the best places on Earth to hide an animal that rarely shows itself fully.
The Monster and the Mind
Even if giant eels explain some sightings, the lake monster phenomenon isn’t just biological. It’s psychological. Lakes create perfect conditions for misinterpretation. Fog, distance, silence, and depth generate the feeling of presence long before any creature appears.
But the eel theory stands at the crossroads of imagination and possibility.
It gives witnesses something tangible to latch onto.
It gives scientists a hypothesis they can investigate.
It gives skeptics a grounded explanation.
It gives believers a creature that doesn’t need to be extinct for sixty million years.
It gives the legend a body.
So, Could Unknown Eels Explain Lake Monsters?
They could.
Not in every case. Not in every lake. Not for every story involving dramatic necks rising high above the surface.
But in the majority of sightings—those fleeting shapes, those rolling humps, those sudden dark movements crossing the water—an enormous eel fits almost perfectly.
And the absence of proof is not the absence of possibility. Eels have tricked us for centuries. They vanish into silt. They migrate into oceans we cannot follow. They spawn in places we have never seen. They live entire lives without offering a clear explanation of themselves.
If any creature on Earth could hide in the depths of a cold, dark lake and only surface in fragments, it would be an eel.
Maybe the real monsters in the lakes are not relic reptiles or supernatural beings.
Maybe they’re simply creatures we haven’t measured yet.
Creatures that bend the light, stir the imagination, and vanish before our certainty can catch up.
Creatures that make even the most rational observer pause at the shoreline and admit, quietly, “Something could be down there.”
Continue the Expedition
Icelands Legendary Lake Serpent
Bessie - Lake Eerie Monster
Ogopogo Case File
Bring a Legend home from our Cryptid Curiosities Collection