Theodore Roosevelt and the Bauman Bigfoot Encounter
There are strange tales tucked into old frontier literature, but only a few read like the author was trying not to believe the story he was passing along. The Bauman account sits squarely in that uneasy place. It appears in Theodore Roosevelt’s 1893 book The Wilderness Hunter, hidden among practical chapters on trapping, tracking, and surviving in the wilds near the headwaters that divide the forks of the Salmon from the Wisdom River. Roosevelt called it a “goblin story,” one that had “rather impressed” him, and though he was careful not to embellish, he could not forget it.
The tale didn’t come from a wanderer or a camp jokester. It came from a seasoned frontiersman named Bauman, a man Roosevelt regarded as capable and experienced, though shaped by the ghost lore absorbed in his childhood. What unsettled Roosevelt was not the tale itself so much as the way Bauman told it, shuddering visibly even years after the events.
And that, perhaps more than anything, is what gives the story its staying power.
A Trapline at the Edge of Nowhere
Bauman and an unnamed companion set out to run a beaver trapline in a remote mountain pass where a small stream cut through the timber. The place was wild, steep, and quiet in the way that makes a man listen more than he speaks. They found a small glade beside the water, built a rough lean-to of poles and brush, then set their traps upstream.
Nothing felt wrong at first, yet the woods seemed withdrawn, as if holding something back. Toward evening they returned to camp and found it disturbed. Their packs had been rummaged through and the lean-to had been knocked partly down. They assumed a bear had wandered through.
Then they saw the tracks.
Roosevelt describes them carefully: clear in the soft ground, and apparently made by something walking upright. The prints were not the shifting, splayed impressions left by a bear rising to its hind legs. Something had moved through the brush with deliberate bipedal strides.
Bauman and his partner rebuilt the shelter and kept the fire going high. Neither slept well. Something out in the timberline felt awake.
When the Dark Began to Watch Back
Near midnight, Bauman stirred and caught the strong scent of a wild animal drifting into the lean-to. He saw a large shape looming at the entrance, a bulk that blocked the firelight. He fired instantly. Whatever it was crashed away through the brush with startling speed.
At dawn they checked their traps and tried to shake off the night’s unease. But when they returned, the camp had been torn apart again—this time more violently. The shelter was destroyed. Their belongings were scattered.
Again, the strange bipedal tracks ringed the glade.
That night they kept a roaring fire. The creature never approached the flames, but they heard it across the stream on the dark hillside. Branches snapped. Something moved with heavy deliberation. And then came a sound Roosevelt quoted exactly: a harsh, grating, long-drawn moan. It echoed through the timber until the hair on their necks lifted.
It did not come near them. It stayed just out of reach, as if observing.
By morning they agreed to abandon the line. There was fear in the decision, but also the stubborn practicality of men who wanted to retrieve the last of their traps before leaving for good.
A Body in the Glade
They split up, one going upstream and one down. Bauman checked his section quickly, uneasy in the hollow quiet that seemed to follow him. When he returned to camp, the silence deepened into something unnatural.
His partner did not answer his call.
He found him beside the trunk of a fallen spruce. The body was still warm. The man’s neck had been broken, and deep wounds marked the throat. Roosevelt noted that the soil showed signs of the attacker having rolled and trampled the body with frightening strength.
Next to the corpse, printed clearly in the earth, were the same upright, two-footed tracks.
Bauman ran. He did not gather supplies or finish the work. He fled the valley at once, pushing through the timber until he reached safer country. Roosevelt notes no pursuit, only the terror that drove Bauman out of the mountains and kept him away from that place for the rest of his life.
Roosevelt’s Cautious Interpretation
Roosevelt was a hunter, a naturalist, and a man who trusted careful observation. He did not label the creature. He did not call it a bear, though that would have been the simple answer. Instead he suggested it might have been some unusually cunning and malicious wild animal, while also acknowledging that fear and memory can shape a tale.
Yet he did not dismiss Bauman. He emphasized the man’s sincerity and the involuntary shudder that overcame him as he recounted the events. Roosevelt’s treatment of the story is neither credulous nor mocking. It sits at a crossroads where natural history brushes against folklore and where the wilderness itself seems to leave room for the unknown.
Shadows Older Than the Frontier
Long before the Bauman incident, Indigenous nations across the broader region—Salish, Kootenai, Blackfeet, Nez Perce, and others—told stories of powerful beings that lived deep in the forests and mountains. Some were guardians, some were threats, and some simply belonged to the land in ways humans did not. These beings were often described as large, solitary, and uncomfortably humanlike.
Roosevelt referenced such traditions briefly in his own introduction, mentioning “snow-walkers” and formless beings said to haunt deep forests. He did not claim Bauman met one of these beings, but he framed the story within a landscape where such tales had long taken root.
A Death Without Resolution
The Bauman story ends abruptly. No search party. No investigation. No attempt to recover the body. Men died on the frontier for countless reasons, but the circumstances here were grim enough that most trappers would have wanted answers.
Bauman wanted none. Whatever he encountered ended all curiosity in him. Roosevelt presented the incident almost as a fossilized fear—something hardened by time, shaped by landscape, and carried by a witness who spoke of it only with reluctance.
Even today, the mountainous terrain where the story is set remains sparsely populated and difficult to navigate, with thick timber and twisting valleys that hide sound and movement. Reports from similar regions often describe the same patterns Bauman described: strange tracks, distant vocalizations, heavy steps that vanish into moss. The wilderness holds its own counsel.
The Skeptic’s Dilemma
By modern standards, the Bauman case cannot be verified.
There is no name for the partner.
No precise coordinates.
No physical evidence.
And Roosevelt recorded the account years after it happened.
On paper, it collapses under scrutiny. And yet the story persists, not because it serves as proof, but because it reveals the limits of what people accept when confronted with fear in places far from help.
Frontiersmen were not easily rattled. They understood wildlife, weather, and terrain better than most modern experts. When such a man claims that an animal was not behaving like an animal, the conversation changes. The mystery becomes less about what he saw and more about why he was so sure.
A Story That Refuses to Fade
Roosevelt likely didn’t imagine that this lone frontier tale would become one of the most discussed early accounts of a creature resembling what later generations would call Bigfoot. Yet the patterns in Bauman’s story—upright tracks, camp disturbances, nighttime intimidation, and a fatal attack—echo through many later reports.
Skeptics argue that such patterns form because stories repeat themselves. Believers argue that patterns reflect consistent behavior from an undiscovered species. Bauman’s account sits right on the border between these interpretations.
Roosevelt left the mystery intact. He didn’t soften Bauman’s fear or offer easy explanations. He simply placed the story on the page and allowed readers to feel the cold valley closing in.
Maybe that’s why it endures.
Because some places never fully reveal themselves.
And some stories follow you out of the woods long after you think you’ve left them behind.
Further Reading:
Bring home a piece of the Legend from our Cryptid Curiosities Collection
Return to:
The Bigfoot Hub
Cryptid Case Files