The Myrtles Plantation Mirror: Reflections of the Unquiet Past
Share
Some mirrors are said to show more than faces. They reveal the echoes of what refuses to fade. At The Myrtles Plantation in St. Francisville, Louisiana, one such mirror hangs heavy with legend, its surface clouded not by age alone but by stories of tragedy, betrayal, and spirits said to be trapped within.
For nearly two centuries, this Southern estate has been called one of America’s most haunted homes, its halls whispered to host the ghosts of former slaves, murdered children, and a vengeful mistress. Yet among all its cursed relics, none captures the imagination quite like the grand hallway mirror, an ornate, gilded thing that seems to watch more than it reflects.
A House Steeped in Death and Legend
Built in 1796 by General David Bradford, The Myrtles Plantation quickly became a living monument to Louisiana’s turbulent past. Over the decades it passed through many hands, each family leaving behind both history and heartbreak. But it was during the Woodruff era in the early 1800s that the tale of the infamous mirror took root.
According to local legend, Clark and Sara Woodruff lived there with their three children and several enslaved workers. One of them, a young woman named Chloe, was said to have been caught eavesdropping on her master’s affairs. As punishment, her ear was cut off. Desperate to regain favor, Chloe baked a birthday cake laced with poisonous oleander leaves. Some say she did it for revenge, others say she hoped to make the family ill so she could nurse them back to health.
Instead, Sara and two of the children died. Chloe was hanged by her fellow slaves, her body thrown into the Mississippi River.
Whether this tale is folklore or a warped retelling of other plantation tragedies, one relic endures as its haunting centerpiece: a massive antique mirror said to hold the souls of the dead Woodruff family, trapped there because mourning rituals were never properly followed.
The Mirror That Won’t Stay Clean
In the days following the poisoning, servants supposedly covered all the mirrors in the house with black cloth to prevent spirits from being trapped within. But one mirror was missed.
Over the years, countless visitors and staff at The Myrtles have reported seeing handprints appear beneath the glass long after the surface has been polished to gleaming. Others claim to see faint outlines of faces—Sara’s sorrowful expression, the ghostly shapes of children at her side. The glass itself is said to be impossible to clean. No matter how many times it’s wiped, cloudy streaks and strange smudges reappear within hours.
Some paranormal investigators have suggested that the imperfections are due to old silvering beneath the surface. Others note that the marks shift subtly over time, as if something inside the mirror is pressing forward, trying to be seen.
Visitors often remark on a feeling of being watched as they approach it. Cold air seems to settle there, and some claim that photographs taken near the mirror show distorted faces or figures standing in the reflection that aren’t visible anywhere else in the room.
Between Memory and Material
Skeptics argue that the mirror’s legend grew from the same myth-making that cloaks much of The Myrtles’ history. Historical records challenge parts of the Chloe story: Sara Woodruff and her children appear to have died of yellow fever, not poisoning, and there’s no documented evidence of an enslaved woman named Chloe living there.
Yet folklore has its own endurance. When enough belief is poured into an object, it begins to take on weight—psychological, emotional, sometimes even physical. Paranormal researchers often speak of “imprinted energy,” where intense trauma or belief leaves a residue that can manifest as cold spots, apparitions, or strange distortions in glass and metal.
Mirrors, with their symbolic connection to reflection and the soul, are especially potent. From ancient Greek necromancy to Victorian séances, they’ve long been viewed as portals, thin places where the world of the living brushes up against the dead. To those who visit The Myrtles, the mirror’s strange activity feels like more than oxidation and humidity. It feels like grief looking back.
An Invitation to Gaze
Even without ghosts, the Myrtles mirror carries a presence that unnerves. Its ornate frame, carved in heavy baroque flourishes, catches the low light of the plantation’s halls like trapped fire. The air near it feels weighted, and silence seems to deepen there, as though the room itself is holding its breath.
Visitors often find themselves staring too long, drawn in by something they can’t name. Perhaps it’s the suggestion of movement behind the glass. Perhaps it’s the eerie thought that mirrors, in their quiet way, remember.
The Myrtles Plantation has been featured on countless paranormal shows, from Ghost Hunters to Unsolved Mysteries, each revisiting the same enduring question: are the dead truly reflected there, or is it our own fascination with tragedy that gives them shape?
No one can say for certain. The mirror remains, as it always has, both artifact and story—a surface where history and haunting overlap. And if you ever visit St. Francisville and walk the dim corridor where it hangs, you may find yourself glancing into that ancient glass just a little too long.
Look closely enough, they say, and you might not like what looks back.
Further Reading in Haunted Objects
→ Explore the Haunted Objects Collection